Despite the deployment of more than 5,000 police and soldiers, the installation of eight camps and the use of 600 logistics resources, the patrols combined between the National Civil Police (PNC) and the Army, from February 21 to March 17, led to seven catches, the seizure of a motorcycle, a firearm and a mobile phone; Results that, according to analysts, do not reflect significant advances in the reduction of violence.
In the last February, the Ministries of the Interior and Defense decided to install six camps combined with agents of the PNC and the Army.
Currently, the camps work on Bolívar Avenue; Paraíso 2 neighborhood, zone 18; The El Búcaro and El Mezquital colonies, in Villa Nueva; on the route to El Salvador, and in Amatitlán.
According to the National Civil Police (PNC), a second phase is followed that consists of installing camps in other points with greater incidence of violence, such as San Pedro Ayampuc; Boca del Monte, in Villa Canales; and the Cerinal, Santa Rosa. In addition, the camps will be maintained in the areas included in the first phase.
Results
In the first phase, according to the National Civil Police (PNC), documentation was requested to 23 thousand 472 people, 7,540 vehicles, 12 thousand 690 motorcycles and 41 firearms were identified. As part of these actions, seven people were captured, three with an arrest warrant and four in flagrance.
A firearm without documentation, six ammunition, a mobile phone was also seized and a motorcycle was seized.
The combined patrols were made up of 3,746 PNC agents and 1,381 soldiers. 600 vehicles were used, between patrols and motorcycles.
The spokesman of the PNC, Edwin Monroy, said that these are positive results for the institution and that they demonstrate the effectiveness of the joint operations between the police and the army.
Low results
For the researcher in security issues Federico Reyes, the dimension of human and logistics deployment is considerable, but the results reported so far generate reasonable doubts about their real effectiveness.
Reyes points out that the seven catches between February 21 and March 17 “Powerfully calls attention”, especially when comparing it with the 5,127 agents and mobilized soldiers. In his opinion, some of the detainees could have been involved in minor crimes, such as drug sales, drunk or administrative offenses, while only three were captured with current judicial orders.
Reyes believes that the police presence possibly dissuade the commission of crimes, which considers positive, although difficult to verify, or the detection, surveillance and intervention system remains little effective.
In addition, the expert questions the little clarity of the official report, for example, it mentions that some data, such as the seized ammunition, are not sufficiently detailed and there are many zero figures that, although they could be interpreted as the absence of crimes, they could also indicate failures in the identification of the illicit.
For Reyes, the camps were not installed at random, but in places with a high incidence of vehicle theft, motorcycle hinge and other complex crimes, which makes it even more relevant asking how many criminal acts were recorded in that same period and if there was a real decrease attributable to the operation.
According to the National Civil Police (PNC), in each of the camps there are 20 people, half police officers and the rest soldiers. During the day groups are designated to carry out patrols in the surroundings and at night they remain in the camps. Agents consulted refer that, in general, the institution provides food, since, since dining rooms were installed in some police stations, they move to the camps.
No changes
The most recent report of the National Economic Research Center (one hundred) indicates that in March 2025 69 homicides were registered more than in the same month of the previous year.
The data shows that the year -on -year rate increased and, in March of this year, it was located in 17 homicides per 100,000 inhabitants. The same report states that, in the first quarter of 2025, there were 190 homicides more than in the same period of 2024, with the greatest increase in the month of February.
For Walter Menchú, a hundred investigator, the data presented by the National Civil Police (PNC) on joint operations with the Army must be analyzed with caution. He points out that, although the report offers figures on actions carried out – as identification of people and vehicles or seizure of objects – these are barely indicators of operational activity and not necessarily of specific results in security. In his opinion, a more rigorous evaluation would require comparing these data with periods in which combined patrols were not implemented, to determine if they are really having an impact on crime reduction.
Menchú warns that, according to their observations, crime rates have not only decreased, but have shown an increase in the metropolitan area, especially in areas such as 18, 7 and 21.
“What we have observed is that crime rates have gone up despite these plans, that is, they are not having an effect on reducing crime,” he said.
Even with the increase in operations and identification of people and vehicles, the number of catches remains low, which reflects – according to the analyst – a little effectiveness of the strategy in terms of prevention and deterrence of the crime.
In addition, the one hundred researcher emphasizes that it is not enough to show how many resources have been mobilized or how many controls have been done. The truly relevant, he indicates, is whether these actions translate into homicide reduction, captures of people with pending orders or decrease in property against property, such as motorcycle theft, which has also shown an upward trend. From their perspective, current patrols not only lack strong results, but they could be serving more as a symbolic response than as a strategy with real effects on citizen security.
Recognize figures
On May 5, the Minister of the Interior, Francisco Jiménez, in a press conference acknowledged that during the first four months of 2025 there has been an increase in homicides compared to the same months of 2024, although, according to him, a decrease in other crimes is reported or the trend is maintained.
On that same date he said that they do not have the exact science that “allows them to establish causalities”, but an important fact is that 60% of homicides are linked to maras or gangs.
It was tried to obtain a position from Minister Jiménez about the results of the combined patrols but it was not possible.
Combined patrol results between February 21 to March 17 according to the PNC.
- Identified people 23,472
Motorcycles identified 12,690
7,540 identified vehicles
Identified Firearms 12,690
Total identified elements 43,743 - Apprehended by order of judge 3
Apprehended in flagrance 4
Seized firearms 1
Loaders/hoppers seized 0
Seized ammunition 6
Seizers seized 1
Seized vehicles 0
Confiscated motorcycles 1
Recovered vehicles 0
Recovered motorcycles 0
Marijuana bags 0
Cocaine fangs 0 - Operations carried out 428
Supervisions 1,372
Mobilized logistics resources 668
1,381 soldiers - PNC 3,746 agents
